I decided to do my paper on the topic of Mythos and
Logos that we discussed in class. I will discuss what they are and what I think
of them. I will start by talking about Mythos.
In the academic fields of
mythology, mythography, or folkloristics, a myth (mythos) is a sacred story
concerning the origins of the world or how the world and the creatures in it
came to have their present form. The active beings in myths are generally gods
and heroes. Myths often are said to take place before recorded history begins.
In saying that a myth is a sacred narrative, what is meant is that a myth is
believed to be true by people who attach religious or spiritual significance to
it. Use of the term by scholars does not imply that the narrative is either
true or false. See also legend and tale.
A myth in popular use is
something that is widely believed to be false. This usage, which is often
pejorative, arose from labeling the religious myths and beliefs of other
cultures as being incorrect, but it has spread to cover non-religious beliefs
as well. Because of this usage, many people take offense when the religious
narratives they believe to be true are called myths. This usage is frequently
confused with fiction, legend, fairy tale, folklore, fable, and urban legend,
each of which has a distinct meaning in academia. Now we will look at Logos.
Logos is an important term in
philosophy, analytical psychology, rhetoric and religion. Its semantic field
extends beyond "word" to notions such as "thought, speech,
account, meaning, reason, proportion, principle, standard", or
"logic". In English, the word is the root of "log", of
"logic," and of the "-ology" suffix.
Heraclitus established the term
in Western philosophy as meaning the fundamental order of the cosmos. The
sophists used the term to mean discourse, and Aristotle applied the term to
argument from reason. After Judaism came under Hellenistic influence, Philo
adopted the term into Jewish philosophy. The Gospel of John identifies Jesus as
the incarnation of the Logos, through which all things are made. The gospel
further identifies the Logos as God (theos), providing scriptural support for
the trinity. It is this sense, the Logos as Jesus Christ and God, which is most
common in popular culture.
In ordinary, non-technical
Greek, logos had two overlapping meanings: It meant an instance of speaking:
"sentence, saying, oration"; the antithesis with ergon
("action" or "work") was a commonplace. Despite the
conventional translation as "word", it is not used for a word in the
grammatical sense; that's lexis. It also means the inward intention underlying
the speech act: "opinion, thought, grounds for belief, common sense".
Heraclitus (c 535–475 BCE)
established the term in Western philosophy and was one of the first to
associate it with fire. One must not follow what is common; but, even though
the Logos is common, most people live as though they possessed their own
understanding of it. The common is what is open to all, what can be seen and
heard by all. To see is to let in with open eyes what is open to view, i.e.
what is lit up and revealed to all. The dead neither see nor hear; they are not
closed. No light shines in them; no speech sounds in them. And yet, even they
participate in the cosmos. The extinguished ones also belong to the continuum
of lighting and extinguishing that is the common cosmos. The dead touch upon
the living sleeping, who in turn touch upon the living waking.
Heraclitus also used Logos to
mean the undifferentiated material substrate from which all things came:
"Listening not to me but to the Logos it is wise to agree that all
[things] are one." In this
sense, Logos is the arche, the first principle of the cosmos in Pre-Socratic
philosophy. Logos therefore designates both the material substrate itself and
the universal, mechanical, "just" way in which this substrate
manifests itself in and as individual things; that is, it subsumes within
itself the later Platonic distinction (in Timaeus) between "form" and
"matter".
By the 300s BC, the time of
Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle, logos described the faculty of human reason and the knowledge
men had of the world and of each other. Plato allowed his characters to engage
in the conceit of describing logos as a living being in some of his
dialogues. The development of the
Academy with hypomnemata brought logos closer to the literal text. Aristotle, who studied under Plato,
first developed the concept of logic as depicting the rules of human
rationality. The Stoics understood Logos as the animating power of the
universe.
Aristotle defined logos as
argument from reason, one of the three modes of persuasion. The other two modes
are pathos, emotional appeal, and ethos, reputation and credibility. An
argument based on logos needs to be logical, and in fact the term logic derives
from it. Logos normally implies numbers, polls, and other mathematical or
scientific data.
In Christianity, the prologue of
the Gospel of John calls Jesus "the Logos". Christians who profess
belief in the Trinity often consider this to be a central text in their belief
that Jesus is the Divine Son of God, in connection with the idea that God and
Jesus are equals.
As you can see Mythos is a story
that explains how something in the world happened. Logos is a logical
well-reasoned explanation of how things happened. I like to explain things in a
more Logos manner. I believe it is harder to be told you are wrong when you have
real reasoning to support what you say.
When you explain things in a Mythos way it is basically just telling a
story. Stories donŐt really have any logical backing. I just think it makes more sense to have reasoning to say
what you say.