Major Events in Progressive Imperialism
Abortive Hawaiian
Annexation
1876: tariff reciprocity treaty led to high sugar imports;
renewed in 1883
1887: planter’s revolt lead to shadow
take-over by white population
1890: McKinley tariff eliminated tariffs on all sugar and
subsidized US producers; Hawaiian economy hurt
1893: native queen takes power, and is resisted by planters,
who favor annexation
1898: with Spanish-American war, US annexes
Spanish-American War
-
2,446
dead in Spanish-American War
-
roughly
5,000 in Philippine Insurrection
-
support
for ‘imperialism’ declines
-
Resistance
continues beyond 1902
Indirect rule in Cuba and Puerto Rico
Cuban constitution convention convened to provide local government but …
US required from Cuba
- right to intervene to preserve republican government
- naval base at Guantanamo
- limit on amount of foreign debt (to prevent European influence)
similar local government provisions provided in PR.
Administration of US Diplomacy
- not a professional foreign service
- diplomats often had financial interests in the countries they served
- limited supervision from DC
- US and foreign firms had extensive presence in the countries
T. Roosevelt (1901-1909)
- succeeds McKinley, who dies in office
- strong Progressive domestically
- supporter of vigorous foreign policy
- enhances US navy
- mediates treaty w/ Russia and Japan
Interventions in Caribbean
Building the Panama Canal
- 1901: US obtains exclusive rights to fortify a canal across Central America, but where to build: Nicaragua v. Panama?
- 1902: US buys rights in Panama from French company for $40 million; offers Colombia $10 million, plus $250,000 annually for canal rights;
- Colombian gov’t turns down the offer
- 1903: US forces aid Panamanian rebels in seceding from Colombia
- difficult treaty fight in Senate; anti-imperialist opposed means of acquisition
Venezuela, 1902-03
- TR supports joint German, French, and British bombardment to force Venez. gov’t to pay debts
- TR later worries over this precedent
Dominican Republic
- SD defaults on payments to US based sugar co.
- TR negotiates treaty to let US have rights to collect customs in return for guaranteeing SD’s territorial integrity; Senate rejects the treaty
- 1905: US intervenes to control Santo Domingo customs during revolutionary period
- US fears European debtors will seize the capital first
- Roosevelt Corollary to MD
- 1907: US-DR sign a convention that puts the US in effective financial control of DR;
Conclusion to PI
PI as Uniquely American
- US is not seeking territorial expansion (only Hawaii & PR kept) or colonization
- US pursue progressive ideals: self-government, economic reform, education
- occupations are "accidental" (Philippines, Cuba & PR all from Spanish-American War)
- Cuba is given qualified independence in 1901
- islands, not continental presence in Africa or Asia
- consistent with American System (McDougall)
- response to European incursions (Venezuela, Dominican Republic)
Myth of "Progressive Imperialism"
- all empires believed they were "progressive"
- brutal war fought in Philippines
- Hawaii, PR, and Pacific islands all kept by US
- extension of continental imperialism during Expansion
- US retained control over foreign policies (e.g., Cuba)
- intervention for economic interests (e.g., Dominican Republic) is a form of imperialism