-
Alpha
#2 now due 3 Nov.; Alpha #1 returned this Thur.
-
27
Oct. quiz is now open-book, open-notes
Does ‘Money’ Harm
‘Politics’?
-
do candidates seek donors rather than votes?
-
Donors
get privileged access after elections
o
Wealthy
have easier time gain access to politicians
Limiting Money in
Politics
-
1974
amendments to 1971 Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA)
o
set
up Federal Election Commission (FEC)
o
established
public matching funds with caps for primary and general elections
o
disclosure
over $200
o
limited
contributions broadly
-
Buckley v. Valeo
(1976)
o
Challenged
limits in 1974 FECA amendments
§
Personal
expenditure limits
§
Candidates
private expenditure limits
o
Freedom
of speech issues
o
What
the law did:
1.
The $1,000
Limitation on Expenditures "Relative to a Clearly Identified
Candidate"
Section
608 (e) (1) provides that "[n]o person may make any expenditure . . .
relative to a clearly identified candidate during a calendar year which, when
added to all other expenditures made by such person during the year advocating
the election or defeat of such candidate, exceeds $1,000." 45 The plain effect of 608 (e) (1) is to [424 U.S. 1, 40] prohibit all individuals, who are neither
candidates nor owners of institutional press facilities, and all groups, except
political parties and campaign organizations, from voicing their views
"relative to a clearly identified candidate" through means that
entail aggregate expenditures of more than $1,000 during a calendar year. The
provision, for example, would make it a federal criminal offense for a person
or association to place a single one-quarter page advertisement "relative
to a clearly identified candidate" in a major metropolitan newspaper. ….….Some
forms of communication made possible by the giving and spending of money
involve speech alone, some involve conduct primarily, and some involve a
combination of the two. Yet this Court has never suggested that the dependence
of a communication on the expenditure of money operates itself to introduce a
non speech element or to reduce the exacting scrutiny required by the First
Amendment.
Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 (McCain-Feingold)