Methods of Persuasion: Support Materials

Aristotle: Greek teacher/scientist (384-322 B.C.)
Student of Plato; Teacher of Alexander the Great; Author of over 170 works; 30 of which survived.

His work, the Rhetoric, is widely regarded as the most important work on persuasion ever published.
Aristotle tackled the question: how do we come to believe something or to believe we should act in a certain way in the absence of knowing “the truth”?

Aristotle details three major modes of proof.  Think of it as three ways that people are persuaded or that we come to believe things or to act upon things.

             We need to be particularly reflective of our use of Pathos appeals - sometimes the emotions can be too difficult for our audience,
              and sometimes we want to use emotional examples to demonstrate the need for change.
Logos is the most complicated of the modes of proof and we examine it both to better use arguments in our speaking and writing, and also to become better critical thinkers when we are in audiences.

Use of support material constitutes offering "good reasons" to accept a claim.

Three Types of Support Material

All three types of support material require that you: Guidelines for use of Examples:
1. Do not use them alone to support an important claim.
2. Examples are useful in clarifying, reinforcing, or personalizing ideas.
3 Ethical use demands that you consider the source, age, and representativeness of the example.
Tips for effective use of statistics:
1. Combine statistics with examples.
2. Don't use too many at a time.
3. Identify the source of the statistics.
4. Translate your statistics.
5. Round off your statistics.
6. Use visual aids.
Guidelines for the use of testimony:
1. Quote accurately.
2. Paraphrase fairly.
3. Use qualified sources.
4. Use reluctant testimony.
5. Always identify the source and the source's credentials.
How can you build a compelling speech?
The foundational step is good research.

You are encouraged to go the the SpCm 212 website under Undergraduate Commons through the library website. Good databases to use for this speech include:

        Expanded Academic Index (on-line)
         Lexix-Nexis (on-line)  has some full-text articles from regional newspapers
        Des Moines Register Index  ( good for local issues).
        Editorials on File  (in reference section) - good for seeing how issue is argued by different
            people, possibility for some expert testimony.
        Statistical Abstract of the U.S. (easier to use in print version) - good source for general
            numbers about US population.

We then looked at quality web accessible resources.  Don't rely on simple search engines like Yahoo to automatically take you to good sources.  You need to be a good judge of sources quality. It was recommended that you try Google as a search engine.

For more info on research for SpCm 212 go to the Undergrad Commons.

In the final part of lecture, we viewed and discussed the speech, "The Ulitmate Gift" about Blood Donation which uses Monroe's Motivated
Sequence (which has THREE MAIN Points). Remember that the attention step is in the introduction and the call to action is in the conclusion.